Preeti Kapoor

                                  Vishal Nirmiti vs Nityas Gems — Which IPO looks better? Vishal Nirmiti vs Nityas Gems — Which IPO looks better to me? I looked at both RHPs, but for me the comparison is quite simple. Vishal Nirmiti • Railway sleepers, MS pipes & infrastructure • FY26 Revenue: ₹339 Cr | PAT: ₹25 Cr • EBITDA Margin: 15.1% • IPO valuation: ~17.4x FY26 earnings at ₹220 • Main concern: high customer concentration and debt Nityas Gems • Jewellery + lab-grown diamonds • FY26 Revenue: ~₹203 Cr | PAT: ₹22 Cr • EBITDA Margin: 15.27% • IPO valuation: ~19.4x FY26 earnings at ₹75 • Main concern: working capital and customer/geographic concentration My View: Nityas has the stronger growth story , but Vishal Nirmiti looks more reasonable on valuation . But I would not ignore the risks—especially customer concentration and debt. This is my personal analysis,...

 Nityas Gems & Jewellery IPO — My View Nityas Gems is into gold jewellery with lab-grown diamonds, with both B2B and D2C business. What I like  • Revenue grew from ₹54 Cr to ₹203 Cr • PAT increased from ₹4 Cr to ₹22 Cr • Margins have improved • Integrated manufacturing + jewellery business • Lab-grown diamonds could be a good long-term opportunity • IPO money is mainly for working capital, not OFS But the risks matter  1. Cash Flow: FY26 profit was ~₹22 Cr, but operating cash flow was negative ₹14.7 Cr. 2. Working Capital: Money is getting stuck in inventory and receivables. Working-capital days have increased significantly. 3. Supplier Concentration: Top 10 suppliers contribute around 86% of purchases. 4. Lab-Grown Diamond Risk: Prices can fall quickly, which can impact inventory value and margins. 5. Governance/Controls: RHP mentions an internal theft/misappropriation incident at a subsidiary. No promoter involvement is indicated, but internal controls need to be wa...